Smoke and Mirrors


You know that scene towards the end of The Wizard of Oz, where the unmasked non-wizard is handing out the things to Dorothy’s friends that they’ve wanted most of all – courage to the Cowardly Lion, a heart to the Tin Man, and a brain to Scarecrow? That part of the story had me convinced for a while that L. Frank Baum must have been an Atheist. As it turns out, although apparently raised in a devout Methodist family, he and his wife later became Theosophists, of which I have very little understanding except that it appears to be more of a philosophy than a religion. Whether L. Frank Baum actually believed in a god or not is unclear, but in any case, I still think that that passage in the story is powerfully analogous to modern Christianity.

Show me a born again Christian, and I’ll show you someone who “found” god at a time of personal crisis, or who, at the very least, was existing in a state of discontent or searching for something
- something they were unable, for whatever reason, to see within themselves to that point. Unless a person is raised on Christianity and spoon fed its dogma from before they are wise or mature or discriminating enough to make practical judgments about such things for themselves, people don’t generally go looking for solutions to their problems or meaning to their suffering in the supernatural. In other words, I think that you would be hard pressed to find a non-believer who is content and has a reasonable degree of self-esteem whose head can be turned by promises of the divine or supernatural.

In The Wizard of Oz, Scarecrow, Tin Man and Cowardly Lion spend the entire movie on a quest to obtain from the Wizard that which they long for and don’t believe they actually possess. Even after the Wizard is exposed as a sham and revealed to be not a wizard at all, but just a man with some fancy gadgets and a big curtain, our three friends hang onto the belief that he – and only he – can give them what they’ve been searching for for so long. In the end, the so-called Wizard (all powerful, all-knowing . . . hmm, sound familiar?) bestows on Scarecrow a paper diploma representing a brain/knowledge, Tin Man with a cartoonish and loudly ticking heart, and Lion with a medal representing courage and bravery. It’s a funny and touching scene, because we, the audience understand without question that these three had the traits they were searching for within themselves all along – they just didn’t realize it.

And so it is with finding god. I’ve met so many people who “found God” when they were at what they perceived to be their lowest points. “My life was a mess, in complete shambles, until I let God in.” I’ve heard it time and time again. It’s a beloved theme of novels and memoirs – people struggling terrible struggles and suffering awful ordeals of the body and mind, until god comes along and changes everything for them. Personally, these kinds of stories always leave me feeling disappointed, not inspired or enlightened.

One of the best books I’ve read in a long time was Unbroken by Laura Hildebrand, the true story of Louis Zamperini, a fighter pilot during WWII, during which he survived a plane crash, forty-seven days on raft floating in the Pacific ocean, and several years as a POW. Towards the end of the book, he finds god. I was disappointed. “Really?” I asked him in my head as I read. “You single-handedly fought off sharks! You improvised to survive starvation and hellish elements, torture and abuse! And then you found God?!” True, when he found god, he was at a very low point in his life, suffering from PTSD, alcoholism, a violent temper and a failing marriage. But clearly, as demonstrated time and time again throughout his life up to that point, he had vast reserves of fortitude and strength and wherewithal and smarts and survival abilities within himself – he just stopped believing in himself. And god and Christianity offered him everything he could no longer see that he had inside himself. It was like Scarecrow, Tin Man, and Cowardly Lion all over again.

But really, what’s wrong with this? What’s wrong with people believing that their strength comes from outside themselves? The way I see it, what it really does is not make people stronger, but instead exploits and encourages their frailties. It’s an illusion, a crutch, and it encourages people to not see the best in themselves, nor to tap into the best in themselves. “I am nothing without God.” So this imaginary, invisible being in the sky who is unable/unwilling to provide irrefutable evidence of its own existence – it gets all the credit. I see something very wrong with that. And that’s not even taking into consideration the pesky habit believers have of doing everyone the favor of enlightening us so that we, too, can benefit from their illusions.

I believe in myself, with all my strengths and weaknesses, and in my fellow human beings, not the smoke and mirrors of religious faith.

About these ads

, , , , , , , ,

2 Comments on “Smoke and Mirrors”

  1. mumofone
    August 8, 2011 at 4:42 am #

    Lisa – I am not sure I would be as dogmatic that people never find God unless they are at a low point – I think people also “find God” in situations of emotionality – swept up in the fervour of a concert, immersed in a weekend getaway, confused by emotion as per a teenager at some kind of midnight madness activity (hmmm…sound familiar!!) – however, I agree that the MAJORITY of the time your point is probably true.
    Having said that you have also touched on a point that I too passionately believe is a fundamental flaw with religion. Your comment:
    “The way I see it, what it really does is not make people stronger, but instead exploits and encourages their frailties. It’s an illusion, a crutch, and it encourages people to not see the best in themselves, nor to tap into the best in themselves.”
    totally sums it up.
    For me one of the things I hate so much is the throwaway line “Its God’s will”. This phrase annoys me so much. It seems to exonerate people from taking any kind of responsibility for themselves. It is thrown around in all sorts of circumstances – “I didn’t get the job – it was God’s will” – what the? Are you sure it wasn’t your lack of prepation or committment or interview skills!! Or another true life story – my sister had 2 friends doing a Uni degree. For some reason there was a misunderstanding with an assignment and about 25% of the year failed. Unfortunately if you failed you had to repeat the whole year. One Christian friend (plus about half the other students) went an complained and were allowed to do something else and were passed through. The other Christian friend said “Its Gods will” – did nothing and ended up repeating the whole year (waste of time and money IMO). It always annoyed me that this friend just gave up and didn’t fight for things to change. This attitude of its not my fault, I don’t have to do anything, its out of my control – all summed up by this acceptance that it was “God’s will”. And why would it be God’s will that one of the people passed and one repeated the whole year – they were both Christians!! My answer to this is that if there is a God he gave you a brain to think with and wouldn’t expect anyone to sit back and take things for granted or make no effort. This to me is an excuse, a cop-out and I hate it!
    There are many many more examples I could make. Many more ways in which this kind of thinking is dangerous, self-serving, arrogant and unhelpful but I have had my rant about something which has annoyed me for many years now. Undoubtedly traditional Christians will disagree with me but this is my experience after 30+ years in the church environment and I thank you for the forum in which to express my humble little opinion :)

  2. Stephanie
    August 12, 2011 at 2:03 am #

    I actually think God is the Self, or at least the way we’ve constructed him is a reflection. So when people say God has given them strength, or when they pray, they are actually only communing with their own person. Organized religion simply gives one the outlet to engage in this behavior communally and also gives a set of rules to live by.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 310 other followers

%d bloggers like this: